Throughout the three decades that Penny Dunn has been blessed to call the greater Indianapolis area her home, she has developed an intense love and appreciation for the wonderful people, spirit, and community that can only be found in Indiana. Today she lives in Fishers, but prior to settling down in her beloved hometown, she had moved around throughout the Midwest, spending time in Indiana, Illinois, and Ohio. After graduating from Ball State University with her Bachelor of Science in Marketing, Penny spent the first part of her professional life selling capital equipment, creating business-to-business (B2B) advertising, and flipping homes.
It was through flipping homes that Penny came to realize her true calling. Driven by her desire to build a business of her own, Penny set out to become a real estate professional and develop a team that shared her commitment, passion, and service. With her unique capacity to see the true potential of a property and her love for serving others, Penny chose to pursue a career in real estate and never looked back. By combining her tremendous communication skills with her years of professional experience, Penny’s team has continued to deliver unsurpassed real estate services throughout the greater Indianapolis area for decades.
Penny’s work as a real estate agent and team leader goes beyond buying and selling properties. She loves the challenge that every new experience brings her and has been grateful to have developed life-long friends throughout the process. When she isn’t bringing the dreams of her clients to life or leading her team to build successful and rewarding real estate careers of their own, Penny enjoys spending quality time with her family, soaking up the sun on a boat, playing tennis, or simply biking through the many wonders of nature that Indiana has to offer.
My Client Ratings
My Recent Testimonials
-
“Penny has always done a great job. This is the fourth property with Penny so far and all has been great. Thanks!”
-
“Penny had a hard task of finding a new home for my kids and I with a specific price point and set of requirements, in a market that had very little inventory. She came through and we have what we wanted and more!”
-
“penny was amazing! she was knowledgeable, patient, and and took the time to understand what we were looking for!”
-
“Penny is excellent! Very attentive and knowledgeable about the area, including strengths and things to be aware of to help make the most informed decision. We're very pleased with how Penny works with clients!”
-
“Penny has been our agent through 3 home sales and 3 purchases. Easy to work with and very knowledgeable!”
-
“Since 2016, Penny has been my go-to realtor in this state. From buying to selling multiple homes, her expertise shines through. I trust her pricing, staging suggestions, marketing plans, and negotiation skills implicitly. With Penny and Molly, my best interests are always the priority. Their professionalism and dedication make them stand out. I highly recommend Penny Dunn Homes for a seamless and successful real estate experience.”
-
“Penny is the only realtor I'll use for the rest of my life. She is the absolute best realtor on the planet and I'm so lucky to know her!!”
-
“Penny Dunn displayed strong market knowledge during our first converstion. She listened extremely well to all of my needs and showed only those properties that met those needs. She accommodated my schedule and was extremely personable. We got along right away and had pertinent and enjoyable conversations during our encounters. I needed a finance agent and she put me in touch with Kristi Kertin of Indiana Mortgage who was also extremely professional and helpful. My home buying experience was efficient and rewarding. I highly recommend Penny Dunn and will definitely work with her again.”
-
“We were moving to Indy from out of town. Penny listened to our needs, pivoted when we changed our minds on something, was accessible when we were available to visit and look at houses, and was in constant communication from afar. She notified us of new prospects within hours of hitting the market, and she helped us negotiate upgrades into the purchase. Honestly, she had the patience of a saint. Her partner, Molly, was also amazing. 10/10, would recommend to family and friends in a heartbeat.”
-
“A wonderful experience working with Penny Dunn. Penny knew the area and had a great strategy to sell our home and find us our next home. She took what we told her and showed us a few houses that fit exactly what we wanted. We were well informed at each step of the process. Overall we are highly satisfied and would recommend Penny to anyone buying or selling a home.”
-
“Always professional and helpful.”
-
“Penny Dunn is the absolute BEST realtor I have ever dealt with. I have never experienced the amount of dedication, integrity and compassion in any other realtor. I highly recommend Penny Dunn! 10 +++ stars”
-
“I would recommend penny dunne as the best realtor for family and friends”
-
“I will recommend penny Dun because she is the best agent that we ever had she make you feel very confident and she is on everything right away”
-
“Penny was an amazing realtor. She was always accessible and very knowledgeable about the area. Her years of experience really showed through and she has a very unwavering approach that I appreciated in dealing with her. I would highly recommend her as a realtor for anyone in need.”
-
“Penny was my obvious choice of a Realtor BUT every step of the way she was supportive, patient and explained the pros and cons of everything. Her professionalize and communication from beginning to end made it a seemless transaction.”
-
“We have worked with Penny Dunn multiple times in the past. She is always quick, efficient and easy to work with. I know if I can Penny, she will get the job done!”
-
“Penny and Molly are amazing! And by far above par with their thoughtfulness, attention to detail, and follow up our what all organizations need. You are lucky to have these two!”
-
“Penny’s exceptional service benefitted my family so much! Being new to Indiana and having lived outside the United States for many years, I found myself at a real disadvantage regarding where and how to look for homes. After contacting Penny, I soon realized that she would make the house hunting process much easier. She took the time to get to know the specifics of what my family was looking for. She went above and beyond to provide tailored results and meet me to tour homes, while providing valuable insight which helped me to make the right decisions at the right time. Her excellent advice and know-how guided us to purchase a new home which we absolutely love! Penny’s superior professionalism and courtesy helped us to be much more at ease during the stressful evolution of house hunting and buying. My family is so thankful we picked her!!!”
-
“Penny was wonderful. Very helpful and attentive. Walked me through the process with ease. Always available to me!!! All went smoothly Penny is just wonderful. Professional yet friendly and attentive.”
-
“Penny Dunn and her team are THE ABSOLUTE BEST! When purchasing back in 2018, her knowledge on the area and her taking my 4year old into consideration was critical! She ended up being the key player in helping the sellers realtor learn how to accomodate the sale of a foreclosure home. Even after closing on the home, Penny and her team stayed in touch over the next 3.5years. It made it SUCH an easy decision to utilize her and her team to sell the home which went through FLAWLESSLY!!”
-
“Penny is among the best! She truly makes you feel like a priority. Communication is vital and Penny delivers!”
-
“Please use any above comments”
-
“Caring attitude. Went that extra mile. Pulled me off ceiling when needed”
-
“It was so easy, the minute I spoke with her I knew she was exceptional. Penny was professional and extremely knowledgeable. She was their for my family 24/7. She was always willing to go the extra mile with her time. Best agent ever.”
-
“We faced many challenges along our journey to our new home in Indiana. Penny met those challenges with us as an supportive and thoughtful realtor would.”
-
“Penny was wonderful all the way around for our home buying process. She was professional, kind, and quick to respond to our needs. When we sent Penny homes that we wanted to look at, she was quick to get back with us and get us scheduled for the times we wanted to go see them. Penny found us the home of our dreams within 1 week of searching. She got us the home we wanted and helped us beat 10 other offers. I would say that she knows the market VERY well! I would use Penny for any future buying or selling and would recommend her to family/friends.”
-
“Penny is best agent I have ever worked with. I would and have recommended her to friends and family.”
-
“Penny helped walk me through purchasing my first home which was a very daunting task at first! She was incredibly knowledgeable and went out of her way to make this an amazing experience for me.”
-
“Penny was very responsive and helpful. She was with us every step of the way and was always friendly and professional. I would highly recommend her!”
-
“I truly trusted Penny”
-
“Penny quickly understood our wants and needs and found us a great home that suits us well. An outstanding professional to work with!”
-
“Selecting a Realtor is the most important first step once you decide to sell. It’s important to pick someone who you can trust and who will be honest with you. My experience with Penny couldn’t have been better and I recommend her.”
-
“Penny is friendly yet professional. She can understand our needs and figure out creative ways to meet those needs.”
-
“Penny is the consummate professional. She knows her stuff and advocates for her clients. She helped us find and purchase our forever home in an absolutely CRAZY market and she did it all with a lot of humor and grace. She's the total package.”
-
“Penny was so helpful and answered all our questions helping us feel knowledgeable and confident throughout the process!”
-
“I would recommend Penny Dunn to anyone the needs to sale a property”
-
“It was a pleasure having Penny Dunn guide us through the process of buying and selling a home. Penny is very professional but at the same time puts her clients at ease with her friendly demeanor. She is not hesitant to speak up on her clients behalf. Her communication with us was always timely. We would strongly recommend Penny as your next realtor.”
-
“We bought and sold a total of three houses with Penny over the past 3 years and will continue to use Penny and her team for any of our real estate needs in the future. Both Penny and Molly are a joy to work with: they know their stuff, are responsive, give great advice and make the whole process of buying and selling so easy! I truly consider both of them my trusted advisors when it comes to all real estate and I recommend them to anyone I know who needs a real estate agent. My expectations were far exceeded every time!”
-
“I have sold/bought 6 times with Penny and I would never think of using anyone else. She is absolutely the best realtor in the world!!! You are very lucky to have her.”
-
“would highly recommend her”
-
“Penny did a great job; we saw a lot of houses and she was helpful at each step along the way. Would recommend her again to someone looking to buy/sell in the Indianapolish area.”
-
“All I can say is I sold a house and gained a friend! She and Molly are wonderful! From the beginning of the process to the end, I felt comfortable . I trusted her to do her job and I ask for feedback. She was always professional yet very approachable and I appreciated that. We laughed, she let me share my feelings, and always listened . Thanks Penny! (And Molly)”
-
“Everything went extremely well and was handled very professionally, we felt we couldn't have had a better experience and result. Penny is very good at her job and pleasant to deal with. The sales literature and pictures were well done, and she stayed in touch frequently. She also gave us tips for what to do when making the offer on the house we purchased.”
-
“When I needed Penny she was there. There is not enough words to describe how great Penny was during our first home buying purchase!”
-
“Penny is an amazing person, friend, and realtor. I would highly recommend Penny with any home sale or purchase. She is knowledgeable, trustworthy, patient, and kind every step of the way. No matter what your needs are she is available around the clock to answer questions and help in any way possible.”
-
“Penny and Molly are wonderful to work with, honest, kind, smart, patient and very helpful when it came to prepping for showings! I highly recommend them to anyone looking!”
-
“Penny Dunn made this process simple yet very effective. If Outstanding was a choice we would choose it. She didn’t just make a transaction she made a life-long impression! We had the option to deal with several brokers and firms. Penny Dunn was professional, informative, supportive, knowledgeable, and the most responsive broker we had been introduced to. While your competitors were abundant and offered lower rates at times, they paled in comparison to Penny.”
-
“I have bought 3 houses and sold 3 houses with Penny. She is so great that I will never use any other realtor for the rest of my life. She is so knowledgeable of the area, she knows what’s needed to sell your house for top dollar, she’s so responsive and helpful....she is the perfect realtor!!!!”
-
“Penny was outstanding. Very attentive and checked in frequently with us and potential buyers. She and Molly worked very close with us making sure we were able to view other homes in a timely manner. We were very pleased with Penny and thought she did a great job. A+ all the way around. She was everything you would want in a realtor! BRAVO PENNY!”
© 2025 MoxiWorks
© CENTURY 21 2023 - 2024. All rights reserved. CENTURY 21®, C21® and the CENTURY 21 Logo are registered service marks owned by Century 21 Real Estate LLC. Franchisee Legal Entity Name (not the dba) fully supports the principles of the Fair Housing Act and the Equal Opportunity Act. Each franchise is independently owned and operated. Any services or products provided by independently owned and operated franchisees are not provided by, affiliated with, or related to Century 21 Real Estate LLC nor any of its affiliated companies.
